• Sign In/Sign Up
  • Menu
  • +Clients Back

    • Get Free Legal Answers
    • Get Fee Estimates
    • Find Lawyers
  • +Lawyers

    • Case Diary & Office Manager
    • Post News & Artilces
    • Post Jobs & Internships
  • +Law Students

    • Campus Ambassadors
    • Find Jobs & Internships
    • Post News & Articles
    • Resource Sharing
  • +Law Schools

    • Post Admissions
    • Post Opportunities
    • Get Law School Rating

  • Home
  • News/Articles
  • Punjab Rape Case; Is Joint Trial Enough for an Appeal of Retrial?

Latest News

Back

Punjab Rape Case; Is Joint Trial Enough for an Appeal of Retrial?

Courtesy/By: Neha Mishra  |  11 Oct 2021     Views:1041

 

Case: NASIB SINGH vs. THE STATE of PUNJAB & ANR.
Criminal Appeal Nos. 1051-1054 of 2021

 

BACKGROUND/FACTS OF THE CASE

The case is an appeal of a judgment from 20th December 2019. In the previous case, the prosecutrix alleged that she was gang-raped by Balwinder Singh, Gurpreet Singh is also known as Aman and Sandeep Singh. She filed an FIR regarding the same. However, no proper investigation was conducted and no arrests were made. The prosecutrix committed suicide following the FIR.
However, a cousin of the prosecutrix lodged another FIR against the same accused people regarding abetment to suicide. On 29 November 2014, the sessions court of Patiala convicted (i) Balwinder Singh; (ii) Gurpreet Singh alias Aman; (ii) Shinderpal Pal Kaur; and (iv) Sandeep Singh for the rape charges. But the judge of the sessions court acquitted Nasib Singh, the appellant because he had not disturbed the investigation in any manner. and hence, Nasib Singh was not convicted. Thus, the same judge tried both the cases arising out of the different FIRs. He convicted the others while he acquitted Nasib Singh.

9 appeals were filed against this judgment in the High Court of Punjab and Haryana. The appeals were against the joint trial held by the session judge. The High Court ordered retrial as a result of this appeal.

The accused acquitted by the session judge filed an appeal in the Supreme Court against the retrial ordered by the High Court.


JUDGEMENT


The Supreme Court on 8th October 2021 held that setting aside a conviction or acquittal merely based on a joint or separate trial is wrong.

When can a Retrial be ordered?

As per the judgment of the current case, a bench consisting of Justices DY Chandrachud, Vikram Nath, and BV Nagarathna observed that

"A retrial cannot be ordered unless the Appellate Court is satisfied that:
(i) The court trying the proceeding had no jurisdiction;
(ii) The trial was vitiated by serious illegalities and irregularities or on account of a misconception of the nature of the proceedings as a result of which no real trial was conducted; or
(iii) The prosecutor or an accused was for reasons beyond their control prevented from leading or tendering evidence material to the charge and that in the interest of justice, the Appellate Court considers it appropriate to order a retrial".

What is Joint and Separate Trial?

"From the decisions of this court on joint trial and separate trials, the following principles can be formulated:
(i) Section 218 provides that separate trials shall be conducted for distinct offenses alleged to be committed by a person. Sections 219 - 221 provide exceptions to this general rule. If a person falls under these exceptions, then a joint trial for the offenses with which a person is charged may be conducted. Similarly, under Section 223, a joint trial may be held for persons charged with different offenses if any of the clauses in the provision are separately or on a combination satisfied;
(ii) While applying the principles enunciated in Sections 218 - 223 on conducting joint and separate trials, the trial court should apply a two-pronged test, namely, (i) whether conducting a joint/separate trial will prejudice the defense of the accused; and/or (ii) whether conducting a joint/separate trial would cause judicial delay.
(iii) The possibility of conducting a joint trial will have to be determined at the beginning of the trial and not after the trial based on the result of the trial. The Appellate Court may determine the validity of the argument that there ought to have been a separate/joint trial only based on whether the trial had prejudiced the right of accused or the prosecutrix;
(iv) Since the provisions which engraft an exception use the phrase 'may' concerning conducting a joint trial, a separate trial is usually not contrary to the law even if a joint trial could be conducted unless proven to cause a miscarriage of justice; and
(v) A conviction or acquittal of the accused cannot be set aside on the mere ground that there was a possibility of a joint or a separate trial. To set aside the order of conviction or acquittal, it must be proved that the rights of the parties were prejudiced because of the joint or separate trial, as the case may be. "

Hence the apex court decided to allow the appeals on the terms that:
The impugned judgment by the High Court is set aside.
The entire batch of criminal appeals which have been disposed of by the impugned judgment and order shall stand restored to the file of the High Court for disposal afresh on merits.


Document:


Courtesy/By: Neha Mishra  |  11 Oct 2021     Views:1041

News Updates

The Legal Framework of Bail Conditions in India: B...
25 Oct 2024     Views:6202
Changing an Arbitrator Mid-Proceeding: Legal Frame...
23 Oct 2024     Views:5614
IMF Retains India's FY25 GDP Growth Forecast at 7%...
22 Oct 2024     Views:5595
The Evolving Landscape of Russian Anti-Suit Injunc...
22 Oct 2024     Views:5393
Hyundai’s IPO vs Competitors: How the Auto Giant...
15 Oct 2024     Views:5415
The Validity of Arbitration Agreements Post Decree...
14 Oct 2024     Views:5064
SEBI Issues Checklist for AIFs, Their Managers, an...
08 Oct 2024     Views:5429
The Siemens v. Russian Railroads Case...
07 Oct 2024     Views:5421
Empowering Minds in Confinement: Bombay HC’s Lan...
03 Oct 2024     Views:5544
The Dynamics of Novation in Contract Law and Its I...
02 Oct 2024     Views:5727
SEBI Establishes Consistent Evaluation Standards f...
01 Oct 2024     Views:5437
Landmark Decision by Austrian Supreme Court on Arb...
30 Sep 2024     Views:5402
Key Considerations for Indian Commercial Claims...
25 Sep 2024     Views:5352
Boom or Bust: Africa’s Oil Giants Face Declining...
23 Sep 2024     Views:5478
The Growing Role of Arbitration in Intellectual Pr...
23 Sep 2024     Views:5434
Supreme Court Greenlights Sub-Classification of SC...
20 Sep 2024     Views:5761
SEBI's Employee Grievances Prompt Formation of Wor...
19 Sep 2024     Views:5586
Environmental Law in India: Challenges and Opportu...
18 Sep 2024     Views:6432
Navigating the New Legal Landscape of Exclusive Ju...
16 Sep 2024     Views:5548
The Anatomy of Joint Venture Breakups in India (an...
31 Jul 2024     Views:5892
The Integration of ESG in India's M&A Landscape...
31 Jul 2024     Views:5793
Future of AI in Legal Systems and Conflict Resolut...
21 Jul 2024     Views:5979
World Health Assembly Revises International Health...
21 Jul 2024     Views:5831
Pokemon GO Fans Concerned Over Restrictive New Ter...
21 Jul 2024     Views:5942
Landmark Judgment on Setting Aside Arbitration Awa...
21 Jul 2024     Views:5734
Understanding the Process of Issuing Summons in In...
11 Jul 2023     Views:9135
Understanding the Unlawful Activities (Prevention)...
10 Jul 2023     Views:7667
Understanding the Mental Health Act in India: A St...
09 Jul 2023     Views:7705
Combating Manual Scavenging in India: A Call for S...
07 Jul 2023     Views:7495
Impleadment in Supreme Court of India: A Comprehen...
05 Jul 2023     Views:8477
Unraveling the Distinction: Culpable Homicide vs. ...
03 Jul 2023     Views:7804
Understanding the Difference between Money Bills a...
02 Jul 2023     Views:6336
Understanding the Civil Procedure Code in India: A...
01 Jul 2023     Views:7123
The Rights of Criminals in India: Upholding Justic...
30 Jun 2023     Views:6381
Exploring the Differences between the US and India...
29 Jun 2023     Views:6389
What to Do If the Police Refuse to Register Your F...
26 Jun 2023     Views:6642
Timeline of Environmental Protocols: A Global Effo...
25 Jun 2023     Views:6332
How to Deal with Cheque Bounce Cases in India...
24 Jun 2023     Views:6315
Pursuing a Lucrative Litigation Career in Indian L...
22 Jun 2023     Views:6362
Understanding the Emergency Provisions of India: S...
21 Jun 2023     Views:6334
Environment Legislation in India: A Comprehensive ...
20 Jun 2023     Views:6686
Understanding the Emergency Powers of the Constitu...
18 Jun 2023     Views:6179
Understanding the Emergency Powers of the Constitu...
17 Jun 2023     Views:6212
Timeline of Same-Sex Laws in India: A Journey Towa...
16 Jun 2023     Views:6658
Sir Creek Dispute and Legal Implications...
15 Jun 2023     Views:6860
Jurisprudence of NDPS Laws in India: A Comprehensi...
14 Jun 2023     Views:6434
Impleadment Proceedings: A Comprehensive Guide to ...
13 Jun 2023     Views:6871
Understanding Continuing Mandamus: A Powerful Judi...
12 Jun 2023     Views:8869
Res Judicata: The Doctrine of Finality in Legal Pr...
10 Jun 2023     Views:6866
Mastering the Art of Legal Drafting: A Comprehensi...
08 Jun 2023     Views:6530
Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CP...
07 Jun 2023     Views:12197
Understanding the Laws of War: Protecting Humanity...
03 Jun 2023     Views:6245
Understanding the Code of Criminal Procedure (CRPC...
02 Jun 2023     Views:7108
The National Drug and Psychotropic Substances (NDP...
01 Jun 2023     Views:6677
A Step-by-Step Guide: How to File an FIR in India...
31 May 2023     Views:6388
Zero FIR: An Effective Tool for Prompt Criminal Ju...
30 May 2023     Views:6617
Unveiling the Dissent of Judges in Judicial Judgme...
28 May 2023     Views:6252
Environmental Laws in India: Safeguarding Nature f...
25 May 2023     Views:6706
The Recusal of Supreme Court of India Judges from ...
24 May 2023     Views:6371
Understanding the Jurisdiction of the Supreme Cour...
23 May 2023     Views:6816
Article 142 of the Constitution of India: A Compre...
22 May 2023     Views:7040
Landmark Judgments in Arbitration Law in India: A...
21 May 2023     Views:7272
Landmark Cases on Anticipatory Bail in India: A Pa...
20 May 2023     Views:11155
Embracing the Future: How AI is Revolutionizing th...
18 May 2023     Views:6466
Understanding Narcotics Laws in India: A Comprehen...
17 May 2023     Views:6336
Understanding Indian Laws on Cross-Border Transact...
16 May 2023     Views:7473
ADR mechanism of legal adjudication in India...
15 May 2023     Views:6183
Validity of foreign arbitral award in India throug...
14 May 2023     Views:6193
Scope of Section 151 CPC...
13 May 2023     Views:7779
Detailed Overview on Section 482 of Crpc...
11 May 2023     Views:6723
Scope of Decree under CPC...
10 May 2023     Views:6269
Legal development of Arbitration Laws in India....
09 May 2023     Views:6313
Arbitration Laws in India...
07 May 2023     Views:6262
Impact of COVID-19 on Legal Industry...
06 May 2023     Views:8363
Chargesheet not having authority's valid sanction ...
02 May 2023     Views:6548
Same-Sex Marriage in India...
30 Apr 2023     Views:6182
National Commission for Women...
27 Apr 2023     Views:6036
Law making process of India....
26 Apr 2023     Views:7125
Bail Provisions in India...
25 Apr 2023     Views:6060
Life imprisonment in Criminal Law in India...
24 Apr 2023     Views:6479
Contempt of Court...
23 Apr 2023     Views:6314
The collegium system of Judiciary in India....
22 Apr 2023     Views:5999
Remarriage before Expiry of Limitation Period to f...
21 Apr 2023     Views:5991
Need for strict measure of NDPS laws in India....
20 Apr 2023     Views:6156
Nature of Offence under Section 138 of NI Act is Q...
19 Apr 2023     Views:8596
Order VII Rule 11 CPC: Plaint cannot be rejected m...
18 Apr 2023     Views:7203
Mediation: At the Dawn of Golden Age organized at ...
16 Apr 2023     Views:6272
Central Government's motto should be mediate, not ...
15 Apr 2023     Views:5986
Ambedkar Jayanti Celebrations...
14 Apr 2023     Views:6201
Supreme Court of India calls for Preventive Measur...
12 Apr 2023     Views:5757
Pursuing LL.M is not break in Law Practice, Rules ...
11 Apr 2023     Views:5984
Law should take into consideration realities of co...
10 Apr 2023     Views:5812
Delhi High Court said that peeping into public bat...
08 Apr 2023     Views:6418
Delhi High Court denies bails to AAP's Satyendra J...
06 Apr 2023     Views:6537
Supreme Court’s Triple Talaq Judgement Would App...
30 Jan 2023     Views:6262
Article 311(1) | An Order of Removal From Service ...
26 Jan 2023     Views:6737
Leaders shouldn't disrespect the President or Pri...
17 Jan 2023     Views:6044
New bench will hear Ashwini Upadhyay's Supreme Cou...
15 Jan 2023     Views:6183
Person Who Drove Rashly with the Knowledge that it...
12 Jan 2023     Views:6775
The rigours of Section 37 of the NDPS Act cannot b...
11 Jan 2023     Views:6512
FIND A LAWYER




FIND A LAW SCHOOL



Most Read News Articles

  • Sabrimala Verdict (28 sept 2018) - A End of Taboo.
    On 07 Oct 2020    Views:96495
  • Case Analysis: Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum vs Union of India
    On 11 Dec 2020    Views:74081
  • Case Analysis: THE BERUBARI UNION CASE
    On 14 Dec 2020    Views:71493
  • DOCTRINE OF ELECTION UNDER TRANSFER OF PROPERTY ACT, 1882
    On 08 Jul 2020    Views:70632
  • A.K. Gopalan v. State of Madras (1950 AIR 27, 1950 SCR 88)
    On 08 Nov 2020    Views:60003
View all >>

Propertified Propertified Propertified Propertified Propertified Propertified Propertified Propertified Propertified

86540

Lawyers Network

103860

Users

630

Cities Serving

114

Law Schools Network

59824

Law Students Network

About us

  • Company Profile

Indian Major Laws

  • Indian Constitution
  • IPC
  • CrPC
  • CPC
  • Companies Act
  • Indian Evidence Act
  • CGST Act
  • Limitation Act

Policies

  • Terms of Use
  • Privacy Policy
  • Refund & Cancellation

    Ads & Media

  • Resource Sharing
  • Advertiser(Sign Up/Login)
  • Media

    Careers

  • Internships
  • Jobs
  • Student Journalists

    HELP & SUPPORT

  • Contact Us
  • Grievances
  • Test

News

  • Legal News
  • Post Article
  • Post Interview

Legal Library

  • Central Acts
  • Deeds Drafts [1128 ]
  • Legal Maxims

Connect

Lawsisto Direct

 

  •  
  •  
DISCLAIMER
Copyright © Lawsisto Private Limited. All rights reserved.
Unless otherwise indicated, all materials on these pages are copyrighted by Lawsisto Private Limited. All rights reserved. No part of these pages, either text or image may
be used for any purpose. By continuing past this page, you agree to our Terms of Service, Cookie Policy, Privacy Policy and Content Policies.